I got the following from readers at Shriekfest. I can’t know who they are so, at present, can’t follow up. I just told Denise, the director, that I haven’t been disembowled like this since AFI. Let the gutting begin!
“The Story is below average in my opinion. I’d give it a 4 out of 10. It’s too long too, it really needs to be tightened up. I didn’t really enjoy it either…it felt long. Some typos as well.”
“This script hits the same notes over and over in my opinion. There’s a useful piece of advice when it comes to screenwriting/filmmaking, and that is every scene should provide new information. This script spends pages and pages and scene after scene saying the same thing over and over. I feel like we spend way too long just watching our main character train for his revenge. Scene after scene of this does not advance the story. There’s no investigation, there’s no work, there’s no mystery, there’s no tracking down of the cult. When he does begin the search, it happens almost effortlessly.”
“Decent idea, it’s just not executed properly. You need more sluglines and there are all kinds of typos/mistakes. It sometimes drags…very slow…tighten this story up.”
“Just my opinion, but I felt this script was slightly sexist in its depiction of women. It felt maybe a bit self-indulgent with the way women have sex with the main character.”
“Lots of mistakes. Page one opens without a slugline at all. Lots of slugline problems in general. Reads as amateur. Inadequate descriptions. Uses a lot of flashbacks with no indication. Seems to lack a clear timeline.”
“Flashbacks are bad ideas in general and this script has a lot of them. The story is not clear, it’s too much revenge…it just felt like it went on and on. The premise is cool though. I just wanted more. Characters need more developing, conflict needs work, exposition needs work.”
“Didn’t feel very well-thought out in my opinion. For example, Alina (after jumping right in the sack with our main guy) then finds his gun and confronts him about who he is. Later, Alina is suddenly revealed as a government spy looking out for him and more or less should have known exactly who he was. So it makes that confrontation scene suddenly meaningless and without motivation that makes real sense. Some of the dialogue does not work at all. Mostly, the main description I feel could be given about most aspects of this script is “amateur.”"
“Not bad, but not good either. There is a kernal of a story here though…with some work, it could be cool. Really work out everything again…start over if you have to. Too many mistakes to be sending this script out. Very frustrating to read a script with that many mistakes. Characters….don’t really care about them either…they need reworking as well.”
As you can see, some things are pretty valid. The issue of tightening things up, the question of how well thought-out the story is. I have no fucking idea what people are whining about with the slug lines (some call them scene headings: INT. APARTMENT – DAY). I have mixed feelings on the “sexist” comment. But man, oh man, I REALLY didn’t do my job! And I think at some point, my description for TW was “a good work”? Ha! Oops! Well, the awesome thing about every screenplay is they can be rewritten. Now, I don’t know if I’ll be able to work out every problem in 1, 2, or even 3 drafts, but the point is that it’s possible. Not even THAT hard. As I’ve already reported, I’m not gonna do it soon. I’m still too close to it and so won’t be able to do the material justice. But when I get around to it, damn.
Amateur? That smarts!
Recent Comments